Apple’s $299 HomeView has received mixed reviews, with Siri AI the main problem
Home / News / Apple’s $299 HomeView has received mixed reviews, with Siri AI the main problem

Apple’s $299 HomeView has received mixed reviews, with Siri AI the main problem

Apple HomeView — the company’s first smart display for smart home control — went on sale in the US on November 13, 2026. The first reviews mostly positively evaluate the hardware part of the device, but criticize Siri AI — a voice assistant, around which a significant part of its capabilities is built. At a price of $299, weak AI performance can be a serious obstacle for buyers. The device has a square 7-inch screen, an A18 processor and is available in two installation options: desktop and wall. Both versions cost $299. At the same time, sales in the European Union have not yet started – one of the reasons is the lack of Siri AI in this market.

What reviewers liked about Apple HomeView

Edition 9to5Mac, The VergePCMag and TechRadar spoke positively of the display and aluminum body. The hardware gives the impression of a well-thought-out device that should organically fit into the interior and play the role of a home information center. Separately, AppleInsider noted the minimum brightness of the screen. It can decrease to 0.3 nitsthanks to which the display should not excessively illuminate the room at night. Representative Apple even joked that it was the darkest product the company had ever made. This mode is important for a device that can be constantly in the bedroom or another room. A smart display should show the information you need without turning into an unnecessary light source in the dark.

Apple HomeView, Apple HomeView review, Apple HomeView price, Apple HomeView specifications, Apple smart display, Apple Smart Home Display, Siri AI, Apple Intelligence, Siri problems, Apple smart home, HomeKit, Alexa+, Google Gemini, Apple A18, Apple 7-inch display, Apple HomeView sales, Apple HomeView reviews

Siri AI does not live up to expectations yet

Siri AI received the most criticism. Columnist Joanna Stern encountered problems when executing complex commands for a smart home. In particular, the assistant was unable to open the front door, although the system recognized her face. In another case, Siri said it doesn’t have a camera to view the image, even though HomeView does have a camera. Apple said it plans to fix some of these issues in the December update. However, so far this is only a promise, not a confirmed result. Tom’s Guide compared Siri with Alexa+ and Gemini. According to the test results, the Apple assistant often gave shorter answers and did not cope with certain tasks. For example, when asked about an Audrey Hepburn movie set in Rome, Siri suggested a list of Christmas movies. Engadget noted another limitation: Siri’s performance deteriorates when the user’s iPhone is out of range. In this situation, the assistant can go to general answers instead of personalized information. This is especially important for HomeView, as the device is intended to be a standalone home control center, not just an additional screen for the iPhone. If he constantly needs a smartphone nearby for full-fledged work, the practical benefit of such a solution decreases.

Apple HomeView, Apple HomeView review, Apple HomeView price, Apple HomeView specifications, Apple smart display, Apple Smart Home Display, Siri AI, Apple Intelligence, Siri problems, Apple smart home, HomeKit, Alexa+, Google Gemini, Apple A18, Apple 7-inch display, Apple HomeView sales, Apple HomeView reviews

Privacy and a camera in a shared space

A separate issue concerns privacy. HomeView is designed to be installed in shared rooms, where its camera and microphones can be near family members and guests at all times. Apple says that each user’s private messages will not be displayed on the shared screen. The company also calls the protection of personal data one of the key principles of Siri AI. At the same time, the first reviews focused mainly on errors of the voice assistant, and not on confirmed privacy violations. Therefore, there is currently no reason to claim that HomeView has a specific problem with the leakage of personal data. There’s also a small quirk of user recognition: according to Apple’s documentation, the device may not recognize a person if they’re wearing sunglasses. This should be taken into account by those who count on the personalized operation of the system through facial recognition.

Should you buy Apple HomeView now?

For $299, Apple offers a device with a quality case, a compact display and the ability to control a smart home. But a large part of its value depends on Siri AI, and it is this component that receives the most comments so far. If the main reason for the purchase is a voice assistant and the execution of complex commands, there is no need to rush. The December update should show whether Apple can quickly fix the problems that early reviewers pointed out. Buyers who want a smart display now should also consider devices with Alexa+ or Gemini. In the first tests, these assistants coped with some tasks better than Siri AI. Apple can still close the gap with software updates. But for HomeView, it is important not just to get new features, but to ensure stable execution of everyday commands. This will determine whether the device will become a full-fledged center of a smart home, and not an expensive screen with incomplete voice control.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x